![]() |
| Home | Surveys | Growth | Inflation |
Money interest rates |
Debt crisis fiscal policy |
Markets | Constitution | Members | About |
FINANCIAL MARKETS
This section briefly reviews recent trends in the 10-year Bund market, the DJ EURO STOXX 50
stock market index and the EUR/USD exchange rate. Some background data is provided.
The section ends with consensus and Euroeconomics forecasts for the above.
Updated 3 Feb'12
GERMAN BUNDS
|
Government long bond market:
demand for Bunds ease as stocks rise 3 Feb'12: 10-yr yields: Bunds 1.93%; Treasuries 1.92% NOTE: the yield moves inverse to price |
|
Recent:
The measures taken at EU summit of 8-9 Dec'11 failed to
convince markets that progress was being made to solving the
debt crisis. Safe haven bonds soared. For longer term trends in the government long bond market and some background see below. |
Earlier:
Bund yields plunged in Q2'11 and Q3'11 as the euro zone's
sovereign debt crisis deepened. The bond yields of the most
indebted countries soared. Italy's and Belgium's credit
rating outlooks were reduced and the debt of Greece,
Portugal and Ireland became junk.
In the final months of the
year Bund yields fluctuating widely around exceptionally low
levels as fears about the debt crisis and a possible global
recession waxed and waned. But a failed German bond auction
in Nov'11 undermined Bund's safe haven status and Bund
yields rose above Treasuries, a reflection of how severe the
debt crisis had become. |
STOCK MARKET
|
Stock markets: optimism boosted by positive
global growth indicators 3 Feb'12: Dow Jones EURO STOXX50 2515; S&P500 1345 |

|
Recent:
After the disappointing outcome of the EU summit of 8-9
Dec'11, share prices recovered as the ECB pumped
liquidity into the banking system. Optimism was further
boosted as US growth indicators
turned up. In spite of low euro zone growth expectations and the perennial debt crisis, euro zone share prices have started to participate in the global stock market rally. Optimism was boosted by positive growth indicators in week 5. For longer term stock market chart see below. |
Earlier:
The euro zone's sovereign debt crisis weighed heavily on
stock prices since May'11. The bond yields of the most
indebted countries rose to exceptionally high levels. Uncertainties about the global growth outlook, the decline in commodity prices and the unease about Greece and the other deeply indebted euro zone countries forced share prices lower almost everywhere. Though euro zone stock markets were particularly hard hit. Oct'11 brought a rebound on indications that euro zone's bailout fund EFSF would be leveraged and European banks would be recapitalised. Some global growth indicators firmed, bringing hopes a global recession may be avoided. Nov'11 brought renewed fears as the debt crisis spread to Italy and Spain and the measures agreed in October to "solve" the debt crisis proved inadequate. A failed bond auction in Germany 23 Nov'11 was seen as a further and dramatic worsening of the euro zone's debt crisis. Share prices plunged. |
EUR/USD EXCHANGE RATE

|
Recent: Hopes
that the authorities may at last be getting a grip on the euro zone's
sovereign debt crisis were dashed when the 8-9 Dec'11 EU summit failed to come up with
convincing measures. The EUR plunged. For the long term trend in the EUR/USD exchange rate and some background on the ECB's exchange rate policy see below. |
Earlier:
The EUR was supported in H1'11 by the wide yield gap between US and euro
zone money market rates. The ECB raised rates while the Federal Reserve
maintained its exceptionally accommodating monetary stance. The 3-mnth
EURIBOR yield rose to 1.6% in Jul'11 while the US 3-mnth LIBOR
remained at 0.25%. |
Background on government bonds: a refuge in times of trouble

|
Safe haven
investment: the government long bond market was the
major beneficiary of the financial crisis of 2008-09. After deteriorating
in H1'08, when it seemed that the financial crisis was being
contained and soaring energy prices pushed up inflation rates,
bond markets made spectacular gains in H2'08. In a financial world
in turmoil, government paper represented safety (“flight to
quality”). Inflation expires: also favourable was the steep decline in inflation rates. Even though the yield on 10-year government bonds fell end-2008 to exceptionally low levels, the large amounts of public debt coming to market were readily absorbed by risk averse investors. High volatility: after their stormy advance in H2'08 bond markets became volatile in 2009. To some investors yields were much too low in view of the massive expansion of budget deficits which needed to be financed. Yet whenever anxiety mounted about the economies government bonds were in demand. Quantitative easing: in the US the Federal Reserve announced (18 Mar'09) that it intended to buy USD300bn longer term Treasuries in the open market. This was positive factor for the bond market, though rapidly outweighed by signs that the worst of the global recession had passed. The yield on German Bunds did not decline as low as the yield on Treasuries. The ECB also indicated |
that it may buy bonds in the
open market, but much more modest sums were envisaged. The ECB faced legal constraints on buying government debt directly
(because of its no bail out clause), but was permitted to
intervene in the secondary markets. Yield gap widens in euro area: within the euro zone differences in yields between German and some euro zone government bonds widened dramatically during the financial crisis. This indicated doubts about the creditworthiness of some issuing countries. To some it also indicated that some countries may leave the euro zone. The yield gap narrowed subsequently (but opened much wider in 2010 on the euro zones sovereign debt crisis). Up and down in 2009: From Mar'09, as hopes grew that the global economy may have passed the worst, the massive expansion of budget deficits started to weigh more heavily on bond prices. Yields were on a steeply rising trend in Apr-May'09. Renewed doubts about the strength of the recovery as well as hopes that for a prolonged time inflation would remain low and central bank policy expansionary, then brought yields back down. Steep decline in yields in H1'10: For much of H1'10 Bunds benefited from a flight to safety on the euro zone's sovereign debt crisis and stock markets crashed. The spread with US Treasuries widened as the US appeared emerging more strongly out of recession than the euro zone. |
Within the euro zone
differences in yields between German bonds and the bonds of the deeply
indebted euro zone countries again widened dramatically as the
creditworthiness of these countries deteriorated. Bund yields slump to extraordinary lows in Aug'10: A string of ever weaker US growth indicators brought a startling rise in Bunds and Treasuries, driving yields down to extraordinary low levels. Bunds additionally benefitted from the further easing of monetary policy by America's Fed (the USD600bn bond purchase program) and the intensification of the euro zone's sovereign debt crisis. Global growth indicators strengthen: late in 2010 Bunds moved off their over-bought position on improved prospects for global growth, reducing demand for "safe haven" government bonds. Rising share prices contributed to the uptrend in Bund yields, attracting funds away from government bonds. ECB tightens: strong growth indicators, rising inflation and prospects of ECB rate hikes pushed Bund yields higher in Q1'11 in spite of turmoil in North Africa and Middle East as well as Japan's nuclear accident. Bund yields sink as debt crisis spreads: Bund yields reached a peak of 3.6% early in Apr'11, followed by a complete reversal on the renewed aggravation of the sovereign debt crisis, declining commodity prices, easing inflation and slowing global growth. On 23 Sep'11 10-yr Bund yields reach a record low of 1.64%. |
Background on euro stock market: struggling to
gain height

|
Steep recovery in 2009 undermined by sovereign debt crisis in
2010 After the savage collapse which preceded it, euro zone share prices made in the spring of 2009 an unexpectedly steep recovery from lows recorded early in Mar'09. This against the background of a then still floundering economy. The uptrend was sustained in Q3'09 as a rising number of companies reported improving trading conditions. Expectations firmed that the global economy was recovering, but at a moderate pace, keeping money market rates at very low levels. In Q4'09 the upswing lost momentum on fears that the recovery in share prices outpaced the recovery in the real economy. Though the year 2010 started on a note of strength, a number of factors soon brought a reversal. The financial difficulties of Greece turned the spotlight on the heavy debt burden many countries labour under. As the crisis spread to other deeply indebted euro zone countries share prices declined further. The trend in H2'10 was modestly upwards on mostly favourable quarterly corporate earnings results. Positive European earnings surprises outnumber negative surprises by three to one. Further asset purchases by America's Fed provided an additional boost, though at the same time also strengthening the EUR and undermining the competitiveness of euro zone companies. |
Promising start to 2011 aborted by debt crisis, growth
slowdown Markets made significant gains in Jan'11 and early in Feb'11 as euro zone's debt crisis eased somewhat and growth indicators were mostly positive. In particular the unexpectedly buoyant German business climate gave euro zone shares a boost. M&A activity and hopes of further earnings rises contributed. Moreover Federal Reserve was maintaining its stimulatory monetary stance. The unrest in North Africa and in the Middle East, followed by Japan's nuclear disaster, brought only a relatively modest setback. Positive growth indicators and favourable corporate earnings reports continued to be published. But markets failed to regain the peaks of early Feb'11. The intensification of the euro zone's sovereign debt crisis and the steep slowdown in growth drove share prices lower in Q2'11, followed by a steep plunge in Q3'11. |
Background on EUR exchange rate: USD benefited from financial crisis

|
Fed rate cuts
boosts EUR in 2007 and Q1'08: the EUR initially
benefited from America’s sub-prime mortgage crises and the series of
interest rate cuts by the Fed which got underway in Aug'07. In the
process the EUR briefly reached a peak of USD1.60 late in Apr’08. The
EUR then declined substantially. One reason was the growing evidence
that the euro zone economy too was weakening and that the ECB too was
lowering interest rates at a rapid clip. A second reason was that European banks borrowed large sums denominated in USD when dollar funds were cheap. These had to be paid back as the financial crisis deepened and the underlying assets bought with these funds declined in value. This lead to a scramble for dollars, requiring large scale swap arrangements between America' Federal Reserve and the ECB. Global crisis leads to dollar strength: as the financial crises spread to the developing countries American investments were liquidated and the proceeds repatriated to the US. Still the world’s major reserve currency, uncertainty led to “flights to safety” into the USD. H1'09 brings EUR recovery: in H1'09 the EUR was on an upward trend, albeit a fitful one. Euro area finance ministers and the ECB would may have preferred for the EUR not to appreciate, fearing it would hamper the recovery. President Trichet, although unwilling to be drawn into this debate, nonetheless liked to quote the mantra of US policy makers "a strong dollar is good for America", though he knew this to be a meaningless statement. |
Initially the EUR was briefly boosted when the America's Fed
reduced its interest rates to near zero in Dec'08 and again when
the Fed in Mar'09 announced a plan for a massive liquidity
injection into the economy. But "safe haven" considerations
soon drove the EUR back down. Safe haven flows reverse: Safe haven flows consisted mainly of US investors selling of overseas assets, repatriating the funds (i.e. buying USD) and investing in "safe" US Treasury bills and bonds. In addition foreign investors bought US Treasuries. The abatement of the crisis in Q2'09 brought a tentative unwinding of these flows as US investors made a circumspect return to foreign markets. This brought longer lasting gains for the EUR. The USD's safe haven status diminished. On most days positive news on the US economy tended to be negative for the USD (as the positive news further reduced the USD's "safe haven" appeal). Also investors were reportedly borrowing in USD, the cheapest source of finance, then selling the currency to invest in other, higher yielding, markets outside the US ("carry trade") Euro zone's sovereign debt crisis hits EUR Early in 2010 the EUR started a steep descent as the euro zone's sovereign debt crisis unfolded. Dollar depreciates H2'10 as Fed renews asset purchases, ECB sticks to exit strategy The likelihood of further easing of US monetary policy gave EUR a powerful boost in Sep'10. The gap between euro zone and US money market rates widened. |
The ECB started removing its exceptional provision of
liquidity to the euro zone banking system while America's Fed was adding liquidity through its asset purchases. The widespread belief was
that the US authorities' aim was to weaken the USD. The EUR again weakened at year end as the euro zone's debt crisis worsened again. Disagreement among euro zone governments on how to react aggravated uncertainty. Also rating agencies downgraded the debt of more euro zone countries. USD also received support from growing optimism on US growth prospects (which, however, also favoured investment in non-USD assets with higher yields). EUR strengthened early in 2011 as debt crisis eases and rising inflation brings ECB rate hike EUR strengthened early in 2011 as sovereign debt crisis eased again. Bond auctions of debt-laden euro zone countries went well. Relief was also provided by Japan joining China, promising to back bailout of euro zone's most indebted countries. Buoyant business surveys provided another boost. The Federal Reserve maintained its programme of Treasury purchases, undermining the USD. Accelerating inflation raised expectations of more ECB rate hikes. The gap between US and euro zone money market rates continued to widen. Federal Reserve President Bernanke indicated that US monetary policy would remain accommodating as US unemployment would remain high. This supported the EUR in spite of the aggravation of the sovereign debt crisis. The aggravation of the debt crisis in Q3'11 and prospects of a reversal of the ECB's earlier rate hikes brought a weaker EUR in Sep'11. |
Real effective exchange rate of euro
|
Real effective exchange rate: EUR
gains
competitiveness as sovereign debt crisis intensifies again |
![]() |
|
Policy background: “benign neglect” No foreign exchange policy: as the ECB has as prime task the maintenance of price stability it does not have specific measures regarding the foreign exchange rate of the EUR. The exchange rate regime is generally characterised as “benign neglect”. Officially the ECB only intervenes in the foreign exchange market to iron out excessive short term fluctuations or imbalances. Verbal intervention: the wide movement of the EUR against the USD has nonetheless been at times of considerable concern and often gave rise to “verbal intervention”. There may at times have been covert intervention going beyond the normal ironing out of daily fluctuations (the ECB denies this). There are only two instance of overt intervention. |
ECB intervened twice in 2000: during the first two years of the euro’s existence, 1999 and 2000, the currency depreciated steadily giving rise to much hand wringing and calls for intervention in the exchange rate market. It was in particular a blow to the prestige of the new currency. The ECB intervened twice, in Sep'00 in a forlorn attempt to stop the slide, and again in Nov'00. From 2002 to the spring of 2008 the trend has been upwards in every year except for 2005. This too caused disquiet because of fears that euro zone exports would be priced out of foreign markets. Since it was regained competitiveness (see above). |
|
10-yr
Bund yields: to rise
in medium term The bullish case: yields may decline further
The bearish case: yields may rise
|
Our medium term outlook of a resumption of growth, bringing rising inflation expectations and eventual ECB policy normalising, implies that Bund yields will rise back up. Public sector debt may have passed its peak but remains large, requiring substantial sales of government securities for years to come. Bund yields are expected to rise towards the 4% mark over our forecast horizon. |
|
|
|
Stock markets:
promise unfulfilled (reviewed 6
Jan'12) After making a steep recovery from the crisis low reached in Mar'09, euro zone stock markets struggled to gain height, then slumped again. The stock market recovery slowed to a crawl late in 2009 and went into reverse early in 2010 as the Greek debt crisis unfolded. Euro zone markets lagged other markets as the euro zone's sovereign debt crisis weighed. The early stages of an economic recovery are typically highly beneficial for corporate profits. Cost cutting during the recession, followed by rising sales during the recovery, make for a major boost to profits. Even moderate increases in nominal GDP, i.e. moderate increases in corporate sales, generate disproportionately large gains in corporate earnings. Euro zone stock markets benefitted for only a relatively short time from these favourable factors. The sovereign debt crisis regularly cropped up, creating uncertainty. As 2011 progressed the global growth indicators became increasingly negative. Fears of a renewed recession brought plunging stock markets in Aug-Sep'11. October's modest revival was reversed in Nov'11 as the debt crisis took another turn for the worse. |
Bright
medium term prospects? The ECB has lowered its rates and may lower them again, possibly as low as 0.5% as growth turns negative and already high unemployment rises further. In America the Federal Reserve has made its monetary policy stance even more accommodating than it already was. A recession in Europe may be brief and corporate profits may again benefit as growth resumes and unit labour costs ease. In spite of the euro zone's debt crisis remaining unresolved, stock markets are off the lows reached in Sep'11. Negative news is being absorbed without great loss. Signs of a resumption of growth in the US and in some emerging markets have raised hopes that the global economy may strengthen in 2012. Corporate earnings results are often above expectations.
|
|
|
|
EUR/USD
exchange rate: EUR
under downward pressure
|
Factors potentially boosting EUR at a later date:
US indebtedness to the rest of the world continues to increase from an already startlingly elevated level. At some unknown point the US may stop being fully credit worthy. ECB monetary policy may tighten sooner than that of the Federal Reserve once growth resumes. Once euro zone's sovereign debt problems ease safe haven flows into USD may be reversed. Purchasing power calculations
suggest that "fair value" for the euro may be around
the USD1.20 mark. At
any value above that EUR may be
considered "overvalued". |
![]() |
Weak growth indicators for the
euro zone contrast with improving indicators for the
US economy. Negative growth in the euro zone and the
persistence or aggravation of the debt crisis may lead to
more ECB interest rate cuts, bringing the monetary stance
of the ECB and the Federal Reserve closer together. A
further decline in
EUR may result. |
All parts of this site © Copyright 2011 Euroeconomics - site by webbex